Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Lifecrayuntildeath's avatar

—First of all, I really like the way you express yourself. You have a very nice way of speaking, proper use of language and structure, something that makes me want to read your text again and again, pause to understand what you mean, and then form my own thoughts on it. This whole feeling puts me in the process of taking a position, and I will do so.

I originally wrote this text in Greek and then asked my close friend, ChatGPT, to translate it for a better expression of my thoughts.

Getting into the topic, I want to say that I started questioning whether I am a performative man myself, since I don’t feel like I follow any specific masculinity stereotype, but rather do whatever comes to my mind depending on how I feel, weighing situations (not always successfully, but none of us is perfect). Yes, of course I have pretended at times, like all of us, and I dare say that this is normal to a certain extent.

Moving past what I am or am not, and going deeper, relationships are complex by nature, and in this era of “freedom,” with the level we have reached in interpersonal relationships and in the field of psychology (and not only this field), it feels somewhat shallow to judge behaviors in such a simplified way without even knowing the other person’s story—even if, at the end of the day, you might be right in identifying a performative behavior. Among all the negatives of being performative, I would also like to point out that there are some positives. I will come back to this shortly.

A break to breathe

My brother used to tell me all the time:

“You don’t know what you don’t know.”

I understand the way you analyze this phenomenon, and personally I focus on one part of your article without underestimating any of it. Essentially, I’m not judging it, but describing a way of thinking that avoids prejudice, and I explain why below. I don’t disagree with anything you say—even though I’m in the same page with your sayings. The point is that it just doesn’t concern me whether someone fits the performative TikTok stereotype, and it doesn’t affect me in any way, unlike someone who pretends in order to harm or deceive others in any way. You’re not saying something different—this has existed, exists, and will continue to exist. For such behaviors, I will invest emotional and physical energy to think-feel-act. But in the other case, I don’t really care whether you genuinely like adidas samba or whether you listen to Frank Ocean and Esdeekid because you truly enjoy them or because they are trending and place you in a certain “social category” that you want to feel part of. I simply acknowledge it as something acceptable and move on.

In general, you can see how difficult it is to open up. There is endless stress, and almost forced socialization so as not to end up marginalized. You are judged for the smallest things, while in many societies even things that, considering how far humanity has come, should be considered given, are still being questioned. In a world where we communicate all day, every day, yet because of the pace of life, fear, socio-economic structures, and many stereotypes, it is difficult to build meaningful relationships. We have superficial connections, especially through social media, where we present a version of our lives—the one we choose to show. We are under pressure from everywhere. This is not an excuse, of course, but an explanation of behavior.

At the same time, since you mentioned Raewyn Connell and hegemonic masculinity, i find myself agreeing, as it explains why in each period and society an ideal model of man is constructed.

Within all this, we are trying to figure out who we are and how we appear, whether we align with social standards or not, depending on how we feel and who we are. Some things change over time. Some, however, remain objective, and I refer to the fact that we are social beings, and at some point in our lives we choose how to behave based on where and how we grew up, what we lacked, what we perceived, what we need to hear, and so on. To not become tiring, personally I love that nowadays everyone can do whatever they want (one of the positives of our era, even though I also value the Platon’s perspective of on excessive freedom), whether that means adopting a persona one day and being themselves the next, or becoming something else entirely to achieve something.Whether it is waking up and going alone to meditate on a rock at the Acropolis, or anything else your imagination can reach.

But there is one rule for me. Do whatever you want as long as you don’t affect negatively the person next to you. That is one of my core principles that I’m trying every day to stay 100% there

Another breath

I don’t believe in a human utopia.

When you test yourself and expose yourself to so many stimuli, you eventually reach a point where you get to know yourself to the fullest.

That is the fine line.

We have almost everything accessible today, yet at the same time, nothing.

Yes, I am philosophizing and drawing a parallel between meaningful communication and the shallow, everyday, mundane communication we all engage in for countless reasons. I won’t elaborate further—I’ll leave it open.

My advice to anyone?

—Filter how you choose to see life. Judge this phenomenon—and any other you like—question it, absorb it, just as you already did with this one , but without letting it influence how you perceive, in this case, a man who is trying to escape stereotypes and experiment with whatever he wants. If you don’t vibe , then you don’t vibe. At the end of the day, he does what he wants, and the responsibility is in his hands.

What matters to me is communication, and that happens when we truly listen to each other.

As you said, if love requires being truly seen, then let us expose our real selves and thoughts. Either way, we will be judged. That doesn’t feel right to me and that’s why I don’t like to judge someone based only on our own perspective and reality when they haven’t even opened up to us.

Who gives us the access to believe we are correct to think we know when we don’t ?

This is my approach, which keeps me one step back from getting too involved with criticising other people. I may have drifted a bit from the topic.

Still, I felt offended for a bit—as I said at the beginning—not because I see myself as performative, but because I feel very different from the masses. I strive to be myself constantly, not to be influenced by criticism, to try new things in order to discover who I am, without feeling guided by trends or temporary situations. Even through these temporary experiments, you can gain something that helps shape your character. We are constantly evolving beings.Ultimately, I want to support anyone—even someone who pretends to be liked—because in the end, they might be going through the worst phase of their life.

-Ideally, right now, I would like it to be a summer noon and go have a “green grass” aka matcha, alone, at my usual spot, with wired headphones and a book I haven’t touched in months, just to see how people would look at me :) I don’t think I will change the way I see the world.

After all this expression of thoughts, I think the time is getting close for me to post an article on this platform :)

No posts

Ready for more?